Michaelangelo’s Pizza

Reviews

• Michael D.

  star star star star star_border 24 June 2026

  Short walk from the Sheraton Hotel and I'm glad that I walked over instead of having my food delivered.  Ordered a sausage, pepperoni and onion calzone.  The girl said give them 15 minutes but it came out in 10.  Hot and delicious.  Super happy to see the garlic butter sauce along with the marinara sauce.  
  Super tasty with and without either sauce.  
  Would eat here again when I'm in the area.

• Jon B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 June 2026

  I feel bad leaving one star because I do like the food, and that the delivery guy called me to apologize to me after I yelled at him--I apologized too--not his fault and I shouldn't have lost my cool.  Just a terribly run business as you can see from the reviews.
  
  I placed an order on grubhub at 11a and received it at 1p.  It was a working lunch for my colleagues.
  
  The guy on the phone started saying he would be there in 5 minutes around 1215p.  When the food came, I was indeed furious.  The driver said he had to cook the food and deliver it too which is why he was late.
  
  There was no toppings on one of the pizzas I ordered, and our salads look like they had been turned upsidedown a few times.  I asked for a 10% discount on my $80 order that included a 20% tip, but I am not holding my breath.
  
  How does this place have more stars on here than yelp?  I'm skeptical.
  
  Do not order if you have any sort of time commitments.  Otherwise, the food is good.

• Jerome G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 15 June 2026

  I placed an order via GrubHub today at 11:33a, anticipating a bit of wait due to the proximity to the lunch hour.  Boy, was I correct - despite the 12:33p ETA, our food did not arrive until 1p and was missing items!
  
  When I contacted the folk at Michaelangelo's Pizza, I was assured that we would be taken care of - the the missing items would be sent our way - and then was abruptly hung up on.  
  
  When I called back 40 minutes later, to check in, was told that the items were on their way and then hung up on again.  I didn't even get the opportunity to thank the person on the other end (not that they deserved it, but manners cost nothing).  
  
  ANOTHER twenty minutes later and still nothing.  This shop is two miles from my order location BTW.  
  
  I contacted GrubHub and their customer service team assisted me with a refund for the missing items.  I will be sharing this review there and elsewhere as well.
  
  [EDIT] Missing items finally showed up, after another 15 minutes.  For those keeping score, this means order was complete one hour, fifty minutes after original ETA.

• Iyanna P.

  star star star star star_border 8 June 2026

  You get what you pay for and then some. I'm a huge fan of the wing 8.99 special and I love that there is a range of sauces to choose from. With this special you get 8 wings,fries and a canned drink. Awesome! My personal favorite is the chilli sweet. My job recently ordered a huge order and they got it to us within the time frame they said and did not miss any items. That in itself is impressive and should be acknowledged.

• Shaun B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  I wish I could give this place no stars at all
  
  Food here used to be good
  
  Warning :
  
  It got bought by a couple Indian/ Pakistan people. Not that race matters
  
  But these people are super cheap
  Buying low quality ingredients from restaurant depot
  
  Which doesn't come on a refrigerated licensed truck
  
  They are trying to create the same food with extremely cheap and low quality ingredients
  
  They have no customer service nor do they even have ice in the fountain soda machine
  
  I had to give my cup to the girl at the counter and she went in the back and got ice for me
  
  My sandwich was horrible and burnt and tasted old like it was re heated from a mistake order.
  
  Please save yourself some trouble and stay away from this place
  
  Bad news
  Bad service bad food
  And you could get sick eating it